Benny’s Brown Bag - A Sandwich Haven In Peekskill, NY

Benny’s Brown Bag is a popular eatery tucked away on Elm Street in Peekskill, New York. It is known for its delicious, hearty sandwiches, salads, and comfort food. The casual and welcoming atmosphere makes it a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike. While some consider Benny’s a hidden gem, it’s not; it’s a real gem by any measure.

One thing you won’t find at Benny’s are tables and chairs. It’s take-out only, but don’t let that stop you. Anyway, it’s about the food, so eat in your car, back in the office, or take a short ride down Hudson Ave to Riverside Park and enjoy your meal on the banks of the Hudson River.

The menu features a variety of options, including classic deli meats, fresh vegetables, unique house specialties, and creative sandwich offerings. Many patrons appreciate the ability to customize their orders. In addition to sandwiches, Benny’s also offers sides and beverages that complement the meal.

Benny’s Brown Bag is a popular takeout option that provides a satisfying dining experience for busy people. It is also a local favorite for anyone seeking comfort food and unusual choices.

Selections From The Benny’s Brown Bag Menu

CHILI CRISP TURKEY – All Natural Oven Roasted Turkey. 6 Month Manchego, Chili Crisp Mayo, House-Pickled Red Onions, Arugula On A Ciabatta Long Roll
GREEN GODDESS CHICKEN SALAD BLT – House-made green Goddess Chicken Salad, Bacon, Shredded Lettuce, Tomato, and Mayo On A Ciabatta Long Roll
THE BEAR MOUNTAIN HOT ROAST BEEF – Roast Beef, Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Creamy Atomic Horseradish Sauce, Crispy Red Onions On A Ciabatta Long Roll
ORBITAL TUNA MELT – Herby Tuna Salad, Melted Provolone & Swiss, Horseradish Pickles, Tomato. Arugula, Salt & Vinegar Chips On Toasted Challah
PROSCIUTTO PAISAN – Imported Prosciutto Di Parma, Spicy Soppressata, Fresh Mozzarella, Croatian Fig Jam, Arugula （Dressed with Olive Oil. Balsamic Vinegar, Pepper On a ciabatta Long Roll
THE RACHEL （REUBEN’S SISTER）- All Natural Oven Roasted Turkey, Melted Swiss Cheese, Rush In-N-Out Dressing. Sauerkraut On Thick Cut Challah （Served Hot！）
DAS HANS ［HAM］MER – All Natural Black Forest Ham, Bacon, Whipped Curry Cream Cheese. Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Ruffles, Shredded Lettuce, Tomato, German Mustard On A Ciabatta Long Roll
SOUTHERN FRIED CHICKEN SANDWICH – Colonel Phil’s Secret Fried Chicken Recipe, Mike’s Hot Honey. Horseradish Pickles and mayo On A Large Brioche Roll
SKY-HIGH VEGGIE STACK（VEGAN）- Pan-Fried Asian Marinated Tofu, House-Pickled Cabbage, Salted Cucumber, Tomato. Arugula. Vegan Mayo On A Toasted Ciabatta Long Roll
BUFFALO CHICKPEA SANDWICH（VEGAN）- 8uffalo Inspired House-Made Chickpea Salad, Salted Cucumber，Arugula, Vegan Mayo On Toasted Thick Cut White

View the entire Benny’s Brown Bag menu.